Equitable Remedies Explained: Types, Examples and When Courts Grant Them
Equitable remedies are court orders that require someone to do something, or stop doing something, instead of simply paying money. They exist because money doesn’t always fix a problem. If a neighbour is about to cut down a 200-year-old tree on your land, or a seller backs out of selling you a one-of-a-kind house, a cheque afterwards may not make things right. In those situations, a court can order equitable relief, such as an injunction (an order to stop or to act) or specific performance (an order to carry out a contract). Equitable remedies are discretionary: a judge decides whether they’re fair in the circumstances, and they’re usually available only when ordinary money damages would be inadequate.
The idea comes from centuries of English legal history, but it still shapes everyday disputes over contracts, property, business secrets and more. This guide explains equitable remedies in plain English, the main types, how courts decide whether to grant them, and how they compare with “legal” remedies like damages.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules vary by jurisdiction, so speak to a licensed attorney about a specific case.
The Short Version
- Equitable remedies are court orders to act or refrain from acting, rather than money awards.
- They’re usually granted only when money damages wouldn’t adequately fix the harm.
- Common types include injunctions, specific performance, rescission, reformation and constructive trusts.
- Courts have discretion and apply principles such as “clean hands” and timeliness.
- In the US, equitable claims are generally decided by a judge rather than a jury.
- The distinction comes from the historic split between courts of law and courts of equity.
What is a legal remedy?
A remedy is what a court gives a party who has proved that their rights were violated. Remedies generally fall into two groups:
| Type | What it is | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Legal remedies | Usually money, called damages | $10,000 to cover losses from a broken contract |
| Equitable remedies | Orders to do or not do something | An order stopping a former employee from using trade secrets |
When people ask “what is a legal remedy?”, they often mean any remedy a court can award. In legal terms, though, “remedy at law” usually refers specifically to money damages, while equitable remedies cover the rest.
Where These Remedies Come From
Historically, England had two separate court systems. Courts of law could mainly award money damages, and their rules were strict. If those rules produced an unfair result, people could petition the Court of Chancery, which applied principles of “equity,” meaning fairness, and could issue orders that the law courts couldn’t.
Over time, the two systems merged in England and in most US jurisdictions, so the same court can now award both. But the distinction between legal and equitable remedies survives, and it still matters for questions like whether you get a jury and what a party has to prove.
The main types of equitable remedies
Here are the equitable remedies you’re most likely to encounter.
| Equitable remedy | What it does | Typical situation |
|---|---|---|
| Injunction | Orders a party to stop doing something, or sometimes to do something | Stopping trespass, pollution, use of trade secrets or a trademark infringement |
| Specific performance | Orders a party to carry out the terms of a contract | Sale of land or unique items, like rare art |
| Rescission | Cancels a contract and puts parties back where they started | Contracts based on fraud, misrepresentation or mistake |
| Reformation | Rewrites a contract to reflect what the parties actually agreed | A written contract contains a clear error |
| Constructive trust | Treats property as held in trust for the rightful owner | Property obtained through fraud or wrongdoing |
| Accounting for profits | Requires a wrongdoer to hand over profits made from the wrong | Breach of fiduciary duty or misuse of confidential information |
| Equitable lien | Gives a party a claim against specific property | Securing repayment when money was used to improve someone’s property |
Injunctions
An injunction is the most common of the equitable remedies. Courts issue several kinds:
- Temporary restraining order (TRO): a very short-term order, sometimes granted quickly, to prevent immediate harm until a hearing.
- Preliminary injunction: an order that lasts while the case is being decided.
- Permanent injunction: a final order issued after the court decides the case.
Injunctions can be prohibitory (ordering someone to stop doing something) or mandatory (ordering someone to take an action, such as removing a structure built on someone else’s land). Courts are generally more cautious about mandatory injunctions.
Specific performance
Specific performance forces a party to do what they promised in a contract. Courts tend to order it where the subject of the contract is unique, so money can’t buy a true substitute. Real estate is the classic example, because every piece of land is considered unique. Courts are generally reluctant to order specific performance of personal service contracts, such as forcing someone to work for an employer, partly because of concerns about forced labour and the difficulty of supervising performance.
Rescission and reformation
Rescission undoes a contract entirely, usually because it was formed through fraud, misrepresentation, duress or a significant mistake. Both sides return what they received. Reformation keeps the contract but corrects it, for example where a written agreement doesn’t match what both parties clearly agreed because of a drafting error.
Constructive trusts and accounting for profits
These remedies focus on preventing unjust enrichment. If someone wrongfully obtains property or profits, a court can treat them as holding that property for the rightful owner (a constructive trust) or require them to account for and hand over the profits they made.
How Courts Decide Whether to Grant Them
Because equitable remedies are discretionary, courts weigh several factors. The details vary by jurisdiction and remedy, but common considerations include:
- Inadequate legal remedy. Would money damages fully compensate the harm? If yes, an equitable remedy is less likely.
- Irreparable harm. For injunctions, will the party suffer harm that can’t be undone?
- Balance of hardships. How would the order affect each side?
- Public interest. Would the order help or harm the public?
- Likelihood of success. For preliminary injunctions, is the party likely to win the case?
In the US federal courts, the Supreme Court has set out tests for injunctions, including the four-factor test for preliminary injunctions in Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council (2008) and for permanent injunctions in eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C. (2006).
Equitable defences and maxims
Equity has its own principles, often expressed as “maxims.” Several act as defences that can stop a party from getting equitable remedies:
| Principle | What it means |
|---|---|
| Clean hands | A party who acted unfairly or in bad faith in the matter may be denied equitable relief |
| Laches | Unreasonable delay in bringing a claim, which harms the other side, can bar relief |
| He who seeks equity must do equity | A party asking for fairness must also act fairly |
| Equity will not suffer a wrong without a remedy | Courts try to ensure wrongs can be addressed |
| Equity follows the law | Equity generally works alongside legal rules rather than overriding them |
Equitable remedies vs damages
| Damages (legal remedy) | Equitable remedies | |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Money | Orders to act or not act |
| Availability | Generally a right once liability and loss are proved | Discretionary |
| When used | Most cases where money can compensate | When money isn’t adequate |
| Who decides (US) | A jury may decide in many civil cases | Generally a judge |
| Enforcement | Collecting the judgment | Contempt of court if the order is disobeyed |
The jury point matters. The Seventh Amendment to the US Constitution preserves the right to a jury trial in federal civil “suits at common law,” which historically didn’t include equity cases. So claims seeking only equitable remedies are generally decided by a judge.
Real-World Examples
- A business protects trade secrets. A company learns a former employee is about to share confidential customer data with a rival. It asks the court for an injunction to stop the disclosure, because damages after the fact may not undo the harm.
- A home buyer enforces a sale. A seller signs a contract to sell a house, then tries to back out for a better offer. The buyer asks for specific performance, because that particular house is unique.
- A contract built on fraud is undone. A buyer discovers a seller lied about key facts. The buyer seeks rescission to cancel the deal and get their money back.
- A neighbour removes an encroachment. A neighbour builds a fence well onto your land. A court may issue a mandatory injunction ordering it moved.
How Courts Use These Orders in Different Areas of Law
| Area of law | Equitable remedies often sought |
|---|---|
| Contracts | Specific performance, rescission, reformation |
| Real estate | Specific performance, injunctions against trespass or nuisance, quiet title |
| Intellectual property | Injunctions against infringement, accounting for profits |
| Employment | Injunctions to enforce valid non-solicitation or confidentiality agreements |
| Trusts and estates | Constructive trusts, accounting, removal of trustees |
| Family law | Protective orders and orders about property, depending on the state |
How a Party Asks for Equitable Relief
The process depends on the court and the urgency, but it usually looks like this:
- File a complaint that includes a request for equitable relief, explaining why money alone won’t fix the harm.
- Ask for urgent relief if needed, such as a temporary restraining order, supported by sworn statements and evidence.
- Attend a hearing, where the judge weighs the factors described above.
- Post a bond if required. For preliminary injunctions, federal courts and many state courts can require the party asking for the order to give security, to cover the other side’s losses if the order turns out to have been wrongly granted.
- Seek a permanent order at the end of the case if you win.
Because these applications move fast and involve detailed evidence, people seeking equitable remedies usually need experienced legal help.
What Happens If Someone Ignores the Order?
Equitable remedies are enforced through the court’s contempt power. If a party disobeys an injunction or an order of specific performance, the court can hold them in contempt, which can lead to fines and, in some cases, jail until they comply. This is one reason equitable remedies can be so powerful.
Why This Area Matters for Legal Careers
Equitable remedies come up constantly in litigation, commercial disputes, intellectual property, employment and property law. Lawyers who handle injunctions often work under tight deadlines, preparing urgent applications in days. If you’re interested in that kind of work, our guides to litigation lawyer careers and commercial lawyer careers explain the paths.
A Worked Example: The Unfinished Property Sale
Imagine a buyer agrees to purchase a historic cottage with a unique view over a river. The contract is signed, the deposit is paid and the completion date is set. A week before completion, the seller receives a higher offer and refuses to go ahead. The buyer could sue for damages, but no amount of money would buy an identical cottage, because every piece of land is treated as unique.
The buyer’s lawyer therefore asks the court for specific performance, an order requiring the seller to complete the sale on the agreed terms. While the case is pending, the lawyer also asks for an interim injunction preventing the seller from selling to the new buyer. The court considers whether the contract is valid, whether the buyer has acted fairly and promptly, and whether damages would be an adequate remedy.
Because the buyer was ready and willing to complete, came to court quickly and had paid the deposit, the court grants specific performance. If the seller ignored the order, they could face contempt of court. Had the buyer delayed for many months, or tried to change the agreed price at the last minute, the court might have refused the order and left them with damages only. The example shows the core features of equitable remedies: they are discretionary, they depend on fairness and they exist for situations where money alone would not put things right.
Practical Limits Courts Apply
Courts are careful about when they grant equitable relief. Because these orders can be powerful and difficult to supervise, judges consider whether an order would be practical to enforce. Courts are usually reluctant to order someone to perform a personal service, such as working for a particular employer, because forcing a person to work is seen as unfair and hard to supervise.
Delay can also defeat a claim. A party who waits too long before seeking an injunction may be refused relief, even if their case is otherwise strong. Similarly, a party who has behaved unfairly in the matter may be denied help under the principle that those who seek equity must come with clean hands. Courts also weigh the hardship an order would cause the defendant against the benefit to the claimant, and may refuse an order that would be disproportionately harsh. These limits keep equitable remedies flexible while preventing them from being used unfairly. Disputes like these are often handled by litigators, and our guide on plaintiff vs defendant explains the basic roles in a lawsuit.
Questions About Equitable Remedies
What are equitable remedies?
Equitable remedies are court orders requiring a party to do something or stop doing something, rather than simply paying money. The main types include injunctions, specific performance, rescission, reformation and constructive trusts. They are generally available when money damages would not adequately fix the harm, for example when the subject of a contract is unique. Because they are discretionary, courts decide whether to grant them based on fairness and the circumstances of each case.
What is an example of an equitable remedy?
A common example is an injunction ordering a company to stop using a competitor’s trade mark, which protects the competitor from ongoing harm that money could not easily measure. Another is specific performance ordering a seller to complete the sale of a house, because each property is treated as unique. Courts may also order rescission, which cancels a contract obtained through misrepresentation, putting the parties back where they started before the agreement.
What is the difference between legal and equitable remedies?
Legal remedies usually mean money damages, which aim to compensate the injured party for their loss. Equitable remedies are court orders to act or refrain from acting, such as injunctions or specific performance. A party is generally entitled to damages if they prove their case, but equitable remedies are discretionary, so the court can refuse them if, for example, the claimant delayed or acted unfairly. Courts sometimes award both types together.
What does equitable relief mean?
Equitable relief means a non-monetary remedy granted by a court based on principles of fairness. Common forms include injunctions, which stop or require certain actions, specific performance of contracts, rescission of agreements and reformation of documents to reflect what the parties actually intended. Equitable relief is used when money would not adequately solve the problem, and courts consider factors such as fairness, delay and the conduct of both parties before granting it.
Do you get a jury for equitable remedies?
In US courts, claims seeking only equitable remedies are generally decided by a judge rather than a jury, reflecting the historical separation between courts of law and courts of equity. When a case involves both legal and equitable claims, rules about which issues a jury decides can become complex and vary between federal and state courts. In England and Wales, civil cases are almost always decided by a judge without a jury regardless of the remedy sought.
Can you get both damages and equitable remedies?
Yes. In many cases a court can award both, for example damages to compensate for harm already suffered plus an injunction to prevent the same harm continuing in future. A business whose confidential information was misused might receive damages for lost profits and an order stopping further use. Courts aim to give a remedy that fully addresses the wrong, so combining money with an order is common in intellectual property, nuisance and contract disputes.
Bringing It Together
Equitable remedies fill the gap where money falls short. Injunctions stop harmful conduct, specific performance enforces promises about unique things, and remedies like rescission and constructive trusts undo unfair gains. Because they’re discretionary, courts weigh fairness, hardship, timing and the conduct of both parties before granting them, and they may shape an order carefully to limit its burden. Understanding equitable remedies helps you see how courts deliver justice beyond the cheque.
For anyone involved in a dispute, the practical lesson is to act quickly and fairly. Courts tend to favour parties who come forward promptly, explain their position honestly, keep their own side of a bargain and can show that money would not truly solve the problem. For law students and junior lawyers, equitable remedies are a rich area to study, because they combine legal rules with judgement about fairness, hardship and the realities of enforcement. They appear in contract, property, intellectual property, employment and trust disputes alike, so a solid grasp of them is useful in almost any practice area. If you are exploring where this knowledge leads, our guides to the litigation lawyer career and the commercial lawyer career describe two paths where these remedies come up regularly.
Sources: Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, equitable remedy; LII, injunction; LII, specific performance; Winter v. NRDC, 555 U.S. 7 (2008); eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, 547 U.S. 388 (2006).